A full answer to many questions about capitalism can be mighty long, then. I won't try to provide a full answer to the two questions addressed below, but what follows ain't short.
Eric's question
The first question was asked by Eric Barnes when we were considering the idea that the pay workers get is less than the value they create (except maybe when a business is failing to make a profit, has successfully--and usually only temporarily--cornered a certain market, etc.). One of the passages we were looking at:
Workers are simply paid substantially less than the value they create. Indeed, the only reason they are hired is to make money off their labor. If wages did represent the total value created by labor (after expenses and improvements), there would be no surplus value, no profits for the owner, no great fortunes for those who do not labor. (Parenti #1, p. 7)If workers are producing all the value, then owners, or capitalists, don't deserve the profits they get, right? If I recall correctly, Eric asked whether it could be said that capitalists create value by bringing together and organizing workers. I started to answer this question by saying that it's managers, not capitalists, who do that work, but then I got a little sidetracked and failed to address Eric's question directly.
Here's one way of addressing the question:
- distinguish between managers and capitalists
- show that there is nothing that capitalists do that makes it so that they deserve the profits they enjoy
- consider whether managers deserve the pay they get
What is a capitalist? A full answer to the question "What is a capitalist?" could run several pages (for a fuller answer than I'm about to give, click on this). Here I'll simply provide the answer Schweickart gives. A capitalist, according to Schweickart, is "someone who owns enough productive assets that he can, if he so chooses, live comfortably on the income generated by these assets.... To be a capitalist you must own enough income-generating assets that you can live comfortably without working. You may work--you probably do--but you don't have to" (Schweickart. 2002. After Capitalism, p. 24). Note that last line: although capitalists don't have to work, some of them may nonetheless do so. Some will be inclined to think, "Well, if they're working, then they deserve the money they have." But the vast majority of the wealth possessed by capitalists who work comes not from the work they do but simply from their ability to "provide capital," that is, to charge rent to, or impose a tax on, those who want or need to use the productive assets that capitalists own (again, for an explanation of why "providing capital" shouldn't be rewarded the way it is in capitalist societies, see pp. 24-31 of Schweickart's book).
What is a manager? Some capitalists are managers; that is, some capitalists do the work of managing. But "providing capital" (being a capitalist) is different from managing (being a manger). A manager is one who manages the labor process and thus also the workers involved in the labor process. Although being a manager isn't the same as being a capitalist, the interests of many managers (the wealthy and powerful ones, especially) are allied with those of capitalists. Managers lie in between workers and capitalists--between labor and capital--but they tend to side with capitalists.**
Assuming that managers add value (as noted above, this is a point that some people dispute), do they deserve the pay they get? Consider the following:
First, it might be the case that (a) the pay managers get for the work they do is itself less than the value they create via employment of their managing skills and/or (b) the pay they get is as high as it is (in cases when it is high, that is; it shouldn't be forgotten that there are plenty of managers who don't make lots of money) because it is constituted by value skimmed from the value created by workers.
Second, in cases where managers do get paid lots and lots, it should be asked whether the work they do merits such high pay. In 2003, average CEO pay at the 365 largest U.S. corporations was $8.1 million, whereas the average production worker's pay was $26,899. This meant that whereas the average production worker was making $12.92 per hour and $517 per week, the average CEO was making $3894 per hour and $155,769 per week (those figures and a lot of the above wording is lifted from Economic Apartheid in America [2005], p. 45). Is this just/ethical? On what grounds can such a huge discrepancy in pay be justified? Is it how hard one works that matters? If so, does the average CEO really work that much harder than the the average production worker? Is it the skills one has that matter? If so, are the skills the CEO has really that much more valuable than the skills of the workers?***
Here it is not uncommon for people to say that it's "the market" that determines the worth of each worker, manager, etc. Those who make this claim often assume that what "the market" represents some natural state of affairs. But as James Boyle points out, "there is no 'natural,' unregulated state of affairs. Without the rules of contract, tort, and property there would not be a market."****
In response to this, an advocate of "letting the market decide" might argue that although the market isn't natural, it is nonetheless a neutral arbiter. But "the market"--or rather the capitalist market--is not a neutral arbiter. Instead, it is an arena in which the rich and powerful (those who own and control the means of production) have an enormous amount of say about what happens within it. Companies with huge assets have little difficulty holding out against worker demands for higher pay and better working conditions, especially when unions are weak or virtually nonexistent (as is the case in the U.S. today). It is on this highly unequal playing field that the value of work is determined.
One other move typically made by those who say "let the market decide" is to claim that neutrality doesn't matter and/or that ethical concerns should not be permitted to alter the functioning of the market. Why? Because supposedly the "invisible hand" of the market ensures that everyone benefits. Here's how theeconomist Julie Nelson puts the point in Economics for Humans (2006):
taking a cue from Adam Smith, they assume that issues of ethics need not be directly addressed because the the "invisible hand" will make even greed work for good. Some business leaders and scholars of business are much more sophisticated in their thinking, but the promarket zealotry that currently pervades much of popular discourse is exactly of this simplistic sort. (p. 14)
Two things to note here. First, those who appeal to Smith's idea of the "invisible hand" to justify capitalist societies like the U.S. usually overlook the fact that Smith would have despised capitalism in its current form. Second, there are plenty of cases of people acting greedily but with bad, not good, being the result. Enron is perhaps one of the most famous, semi-recent cases of this, but we could add to the list of corporate scandals WorldCom, Global Crossing, Adelphia Communications, Halliburton, Citibank, etc.
"But what's the alternative?" some might ask. One alternative is to retain markets but get rid of capitalism. Better, non-capitalist markets can be put into place. We'll see this when we look at market socialism a little bit later in the semester. In market-socialist societies, there would be markets, but the value and pay of workers and managers would be determined differently than they are within capitalist societies--more democratically, at least, than is the case within most capitalist enterprises.
Ryan's question
What if the wealth one possesses comes from doing something innovative? This was the question that Ryan Preston asked. Schweickart addresses a related question: don't capitalists contribute value insofar as they contribute their innovative/entreprenuerial activity? Here's Schweickart's answer:
No one can doubt that the entrepreneur makes a productive contribution. One can question the long-range value of specific contributions but any society, if it is to be at all dynamic, needs people who are economically creative and willing to initiate new projects. Entrepreneurial activity is vital--for captialism and for [market socialism]. Socialism will need entrepreneurs (though not capitalists). The entrepreneur under capitalism makes a productive contribution, but there is a problem with appealing to the entrepreneur in order to justify capitalist income. Most capitalist income has little to do with entrepreneurial activity....To be sure, some capitalists act as entrepreneurs, and some entrepreneurs become capitalists. Nonetheless, theoretically and in practice, the two categories, capitalist and entrepreneur, are distinct....The entrepreneur is rewarded for her activity; the capitalist is rewarded for "providing capital." (Schweickart. 2002. After Capitalism, pp. 31-32)The passage quoted above may not fully answer Ryan's question, but I hope it at least gives y'all (the two or three of you I reckon are reading this) some idea of how the question can be addressed. For a fuller answer, see pp. 31-33 of Schweickart's After Capitalism.
Something else to consider: those who innovate don't do so completely by themselves. Nowadays, at least, innovation is made possible by the education one receives, the infrastructure that makes for a semi-smoothly functioning society, and so on. If the things that make innovation possible are publicly funded and/or the product of social labor (that is, the product of collective efforts), then it's not clear that those who innovate should reap 100% of the benefits that come from innovating. It would be difficult to calculate with any precision exactly how much one's innovation is made possible by the work of others, but that doesn't mean we should altogether ignore the fact that the work of others makes one's innovation possible. Instead, we should take that fact into consideration when deciding what public policy concerning innovation ought to be. In developing such policy--i.e. deciding, among other things, how to motivate/reward innovators--it should be kept in mind that the prospect of becoming fabulously wealthy probably isn't the only thing that can serve as an incentive to innovate. Other incentives could include the prospect of becoming significantly more wealthy than one currently is, getting a job promotion, being publicly recognized and honored for the work one has done, etc.
Footnotes
*Recall what Wheen says in his interview on Talk of the Nation about what it's like to try to understand capitalism. After pointing out that what Marx "was trying to write about was so huge and all-embracing," he says,
One line of inquiry leads to another. It's a bit like when you google things on the internet, you go to some website, and there's an interesting link there, and so you click on that, and that leads you to something else that looks rather promising, so you click on that. An hour later, you've gone down this chain of consequences, and you're miles from where you started, but you haven't actually gotten any further in a certain sense. (If for some reason you want to hear Wheen utter these lines, click here and listen from about 16min30sec to 17min01sec)
**For interesting discussions of managers and professionals, see Barbara and John Ehrenreich's "The Professional-Managerial Class" in Between Labor and Capital (1979) and Jack Metzgar's "Politics and the American Class Vernacular" in New Working-Class Studies (2005).
***An adequate answer to this question would, I think, have to take into account the issue of deskilled labor, which would mean looking into the the history of capital's destruction of skilled work. Braverman's Labor and Monopoly Capital (1998 [1974])--especially chapters 3 and 4--is a good place to look to learn about this history. Looking at the issue of deskilling helps one see the extent to which unskilled or low-skill jobs exist not because there are people who lack skills (either because of stupidity, lack of effort, etc.) and thus are fit to fill only such jobs but because capital has created them to suit its need for profit-making (in much the same way that capital creates corn-the-commodity and all the crappy things linked to it--stuff Pollan discusses in The Omnivore's Dilemma.)
****That there is a quotation from footnote #5 on p. 2 of Hull's An Introduction to Issues in Computers, Ethics, and Policy (2000), which is the first thing I asked you to read for this course. Original source of the quotation is James Boyle's Shamans, Software, & Spleens: Law and the Construction of the Information Society (1996).
No comments:
Post a Comment